We’ve Got Some Unbelievably Small Boots to Fill

american-military-presence

The truncated version of Kerry’s Congressional testimony statement runs “we’ve got some unbelievably small boots” that we can use in Syria. And it brings to mind a conundrum between what is now becoming a long-term foreign policy choice, and how the spin machine works. With a decade of unfruitful and in all likelihood illegal wars under our belt, we’ve now correctly lumped the potential Syria experience in with its predecessors. We’ve got shock and awe, CNN is in the hotel across from the Palace, there’s a great shot of pulling down statues in a public square, the spin cycle moves on, and then the slippery slope really takes hold–we’re still slipping, by the way.

We’ve made it to the second lowest step of Bloom’s taxonomy here ( ‘to identify’). But to really break the destructive (and progressively less popular) trend, we need to make it to the final step and “create” a new solution. We’ve gotten good at saying “there it is again” and “no.” But there are situations in which a negative response won’t work. What’s missing–and something is missing, as Putin made clear–is asking “what else do we have in (or can we create for) our bag of tricks?”

Woodrow Wilson’s original idea for the creation of the League of Nations after WWI was that we could take what we learned and make the conflict a “war to end all wars.” We were learning from mistakes. The rationale behind the few remaining humanitarian treaties we still acknowledge aren’t that different. Some atrocity was committed, and we decided not to recommit it. We used war to establish a more fruitful peace. Otherwise, what’s the point? That’s what’s so bewildering about the current news climate, we aren’t asking the most basic question through which we might make progress. Namely, what are we getting out of this war?

I think it’s precisely for this reason that for a while now the answer has been “not much.” The U.S. isn’t noticeably any safer than 12 years ago after 9/11. The world is noticeably more dangerous, with the average person’s likelihood of dying in an armed conflict doubling since 1998[1]. We still haven’t signed the International Mine Ban Treaty, and (recently) we were one of the only first world countries not to sign the U.N. Arms Trade Treaty. In which it is forbidden to sell arms to human rights violators, and criminals. The President asked us all to YouTube videos from Al-Assad’s chemical attack. But what about pictures of infants deformed from the layer of Uranium dust that has settled over large swaths of Iraq? If it’s meaningful interventionism we’re after, there are plenty of places to intervene (South Sudan, Democratic Republic of Congo). We can probably even profit, protect national security, and uphold “international norms.” If we just HAVE TO go on militarily, why not go in on AQIM (Al-Qaeda of the Islamic Maghreb). Hell, the U.N. would probably go in for us.

This is where our myopia in the big picture gets a little scary, particularly regarding Syria. A report this year from the Director of National Security’s office detailed four potential “megatrends” that they believe could come into being by the year 2030. Only one of these megatrends includes the U.S. as a major global player. This trend involves “the most plausible best-case outcome, China and the US collaborate on a range of issues, leading to broader global cooperation. [2]” China has backed Russia on the Syrian front. Hostilities in Pakistan are nearing open war, on which China has said “any attack on Pakistan would be construed as an attack on China,” and Iran has been backed by China for years[3]. We’re a nation of builders, if nothing else. America has proven time and time again that we can make things, and we can make things that work. So where is a positive formulation of what we’re building in the Middle East? I think that’s all the rest of the world wants. For too long discussion of armed conflicts has been about the proper way to hit the ‘go’ button, with no proper consideration of qualitative measures, or the outcome we’re hoping to achieve. We’ve become the improperly trained k-9 unit of the global police force. Our own intel tells us we’re on the verge of being marginalized, and all we need is a little discipline so as not to be. I bet Woodrow Wilson would be happy with a set of such unbelievably small boots to fill.

References:

1.) World Population/Armed Conflict Deaths:
2.) http://www.dni.gov/files/documents/GlobalTrends_2030.pdf
3.) http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/2152/china-warns-us-pakistan

Other recent stories

Interventionism as Investment

America is on the verge of entering into the least popular intervention in our history. According to the administration’s case, it is now a matter of international “credibility.” It also doesn’t hurt, as Kerry noted that “if the U.S. is… Read more

10 Junk Food Brands That Made a Buck in Iraq

When American and British troops returned to Iraq in 2003 — to liberate, or to invade, depending on who exactly you are listening to — they soon found that many of their fast food favorites from back home had followed them into the war zone…. Read more

25 Veterans Day Quotes

In honor of Veterans Day 2010, which happens November 11, here’s a list of 25 quotes to live by: 1. We make war that we may live in peace. -Aristotle 2. Nobody ever drowned in sweat. -US Marines 3. Those who cannot bravely face danger… Read more

Your Next Business Trip Could Come with a Full Body Scan

One reason Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab went through the security line undetected was that nobody saw the bomb in his underwear. As a result, some airports, including all Dutch airports with US-bound flights, and Chicago’s O’Hare airport, will start… Read more

Open Carry States List

Image: Californiaopencarry.org After reading about protesters bringing guns to anti-Obama rallies, I grew curious about which states are open-carry; that is, they allow people to carry guns in public, as long as the guns are visible. I made… Read more

When DuPont Almost Overthrew the Government

I love a good conspiracy. This one, involving Great Depression-era businessmen attempting to overthrow President Roosevelt in a military coup, just about beats them all: In the summer of 1933, shortly after Roosevelt’s “First 100 Days,”… Read more

25 Armed Forces Day Quotes

2009 marks the 50th anniversary of Armed Forces Day, which honors Americans serving in the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, and Coast Guard. Find inspiration and honor in the 25 quotes below, which apply to all of the armed forces: 1. He loves… Read more

Somali Pirates Have a Good Business Model

Spiegel interviewed former FBI agent Jack Cloonan, now a negotiator with Somali pirates. Here’s an excerpt from the fascinating piece: SPIEGEL: From your experience with the Somali pirates, are they intelligent people? Or are they simply… Read more

The 25 Most Vicious Iraq War Profiteers

The Iraq war is many things to different people. It is called a strategic blunder and a monstrous injustice and sometimes even a patriotic mission, much to the chagrin of rational human beings. For many big companies, however, the war is something… Read more

United States Sold Iran More Than $500 million in Goods During Bush’s Term

An Iranian soldier, after drinking a Pepsi According to Andy Carpenter at HoweStreet, the Bush administration sold a whole lot more to Iran than a bad reputation. He says that (via the AP) the United States sold the heart of the Axis of Evil… Read more

Why Women Almost Always Do Better in Business Than Men

The Washington Post has a great article today that explores the reasons why empowering women eliminates the cycle of poverty, particularly in post-conflict Rwanda. It’s hard to imagine the lives Rwandan women have lead, hard to relate to a… Read more

Halliburton in Iraq

According to this article (sub. required) from Fortune, Halliburton isn't really making that much money in Iraq. It has all the makings of a delicious election-year scandal—Howard Dean has already weighed in—but there's just one… Read more

saddam hussein captured

I think I know what the blogosphere will be buzzing about for the next few… Read more

Buy A Whopper for the Troops in Iraq

This is an interesting idea. Greensboro Burger Kings — along with stores in the Kansas City metropolitan area and Omaha, Neb. — are piloting a program to provide free Burger King food to American soldiers overseas. Through Jan. 15, customers at… Read more